daniel@home:~$

Who is John Galt?

There is a phrase in Ayn Rand’s novel, Atlas Shrugged (La rebelión de Atlas, 1957) that functions as a collective shrug: “Who is John Galt?”—always uttered with apathy, like someone saying “what do I know,” “what’s the point,” “whatever.” In the world of the novel, that indifference is the symptom: nobody takes responsibility for anything because it is taken for granted that something—the system, the state, inertia—will take care of it on its own.

John Galt, the character, is the engineer who built the engine that moved everything and who, fed up with seeing a society that despises producers demand his work without understanding its value, decides to strike: he disappears, and with him all those who hold up the world. And the world, literally, comes to a standstill. Bridges, trains, power grids: the entire novel is a thought experiment about taking away the work of those who made it run and seeing what remains.

What remains is this, for example.

Yesterday, in Urda

On October 28, 2026, at 08:54, on the Madrid–Seville high-speed line, a Renfe Class 103 AVE carrying 397 passengers suffered a high-speed rear-end collision with the back of an Iryo Frecciarossa, stopped on the track following a software crash in the LZB signaling system. 69 dead, more than 179 injured. Spain’s second most severe rail accident of the 21st century after Angrois. The second high-speed collision this year, nine months after Adamuz.

And there lies the chilling mix: a mix of technologies (90s German LZB stitched onto 90s Spanish infrastructure, monitored by procedures that no one dares say they fully understand), a mix of operators (the liberalized line: Renfe and Iryo sharing slots and offices from an Adif that acts as both judge and network owner), a mix of responsibilities (human error in the control center combined with a signaling failure, according to the investigation; meaning: the machine didn’t stop it, the person didn’t see it, and the system—which exists precisely for this—didn’t ask).

An AVE train that doesn’t automatically brake for an obstacle in its block is not just a loose bolt. It is Rand’s question made into twisted metal down an embankment: who was taking responsibility?

Where are the Galts in this story?

They exist. They are the cadre of signaling engineers retiring without replacements because the role “isn’t strategic.” They are the contractor maintaining the LZB in auctioned lots. They are the traffic controller who, on an October Tuesday, gives instructions over the phone because the screen is displaying what it shouldn’t—and has been displaying what it shouldn’t for years, with someone patching the patch with a new procedure for years. It is every competent person looking at their dashboard and saying to themselves, with perfect individual rationality, what do I know, that’s what the system is for.

What do I know. The Spanish shrug shares the same punchline as the English “Who is John Galt?”: both are the polite form of a retreat. The difference is that in the novel, those who hold up the world go on strike, choosing not to sustain it; in reality, they leave in silence, one by one, for jobs where their knowledge is paid for and listened to. And nobody declares a strike; the world simply runs out of people who understand it. Things don’t break all at once. They are left without anyone to maintain them.

Joan Tubau wrote about this recently, that kind of decline that goes unnoticed because it makes no noise—the soul of things goes out when we stop treating them as if they had an owner, and a train for which no one is accountable is not an object: it’s a delayed accident traveling at 200 km/h. In Why do I have to learn the rivers?, from October 20, Tubau warned about the exact same vector regarding AI: even if the machine has all the answers, there are things we shouldn’t stop knowing, because to stop asking about them is to stop understanding them, and to stop understanding them is to stop being able to take responsibility for them. The rivers nobody learns, one day overflow.


Source note: John Galt (Wikipedia) · Atlas Shrugged (Wikipedia) · Urda rail accident (Wikipedia) · Joan Tubau, “Clyde Fans” · Joan Tubau, “Why do I have to learn the rivers?” · Galt’s speech, analysis at ayn.com.


Automatically translated from the Spanish original.

Publicado en: Blog

Tags: ayn-rand atlas-shrugged accidente-urda infraestructuras soberanía declive

Want to subscribe to new posts?